TonyFantis.com Home Page
 Call us at (801) 541-8806
  Send an email

5331 Sleepy Hollow Ln
Nibley, UT 84321
MLS #2073429

$1,550,000

 Available

5 Beds | 6 Baths | 5 Garage | 4,212 Sq Ft

Estimated Payment:  /month 
5331  Sleepy Hollow Ln
Photo 1 for 5331  Sleepy Hollow Ln
Photo 2 for 5331  Sleepy Hollow Ln
Photo 3 for 5331  Sleepy Hollow Ln
Photo 4 for 5331  Sleepy Hollow Ln
Photo 5 for 5331  Sleepy Hollow Ln
Photo 6 for 5331  Sleepy Hollow Ln

Photos, Tours, & Maps

Post It

Single Family Home for Sale

Discover the epitome of luxury living with this breathtaking custom-built home nestled on a sprawling 10-acre estate in Nibley, Utah. This equestrian haven comes complete with water shares, a state-of-the-art horse barn, lush pastures, and meticulously maintained paddocks. The crown jewel of this property is a magnificent 5-bedroom, 6-bathroom residence, designed to impress with a cutting-edge theater room featuring expertly tuned surround sound and a work ready office. Step into the heart of the home-a gourmet custom kitchen anchored by a striking island, perfect for culinary creations and entertaining alike. The entire residence is wired with a sophisticated surround sound and intercom system, ensuring seamless ambiance for grand gatherings or intimate evenings. Outdoors, the custom deck and fully equipped kitchen steal the show, offering an unrivaled space for hosting guests. For moments of serenity, retreat beneath the deck with a drink in hand, lulled by the gentle murmur of the nearby river, or relax in one of the thoughtfully placed seating areas scattered across the grounds. Perfectly positioned along a quiet stretch in Nibley, this estate boasts unrivaled privacy, direct river frontage along the Blacksmith Fork River, and awe-inspiring views of the eastern mountains and canyon beyond. Inside, no detail has been overlooked: gleaming hardwood floors, handcrafted cabinetry, sleek granite countertops, intricate tile artistry, and a stunning rock fireplace that flows effortlessly from the interior to the expansive outdoor living space. Indulge in premium amenities, including a spa-inspired steam shower, a top-tier theater room, and an expansive covered deck complete with a gas fireplace and panoramic river vistas. This property is a gateway to adventure, offering direct horseback access from your pasture to vast state and federal lands stretching toward Bear Lake. Imagine an extraordinary ride to Yellowstone National Park, uninterrupted by private land-an equestrian's dream. Recently enhanced landscaping provides seamless access to the Blacksmith Fork River, where you can reel in impressive trout steps from your door. Nibley is a sought-after haven for outdoor enthusiasts, renowned for its world-class dirt bike trails and endless opportunities for hiking, mountain biking, horseback riding, and more. This rare gem in Utah's Cache Valley blends luxury with nature's finest offerings. Don't miss your chance to claim this unparalleled retreat-potential buyers are encouraged to verify all details and experience it for yourself.

Rooms, Laundry, & Layout

 BedsBathsLaundrySq Ft
Floor 3000182
Floor 24311,464
Floor 11302,086
Basement*000480
*The basement is 100% finished.
Price Insights
Current price
Price per sq ft
Price per finished sq ft
$1,550,000
$368 / square foot
$368 / finished sq ft

4 Days on the Market
Status: Available

Schools, Inclusions, & Exclusions

Alarm System, Basketball Standard, Ceiling Fan, Compactor, Dog Run, Dryer, Freezer, Gas Grill/BBQ, Humidifier, Microwave, Range, Range Hood, Refrigerator, Satellite Dish, Storage Shed(s), Washer, Water Softener: Own, Window Coverings, Workbench, Projector, Video Door Bell(s), Video Camera(s)
Inclusions are often re-negotiated during contract negotiation.
No items have been listed as excluded.

Cache School District

Elementary: Heritage
Middle: South Cache
Senior: Ridgeline
The Numbers
Interior :
Basement :
Style :
Year built :
Lot acres :
Lot sq ft :
4,212 square feet
100% finished
Style: Tri/Multi-Level
2005
10.00 acres
435,600 square feet

Home Features & Amenities

Features: Fire Alarm, Security Alarm, Bath: Primary, Separate Tub/Shower, Walk-in Closet, Den/Office, Disposal, Gas Log Fireplace, Great Room, Intercom, Jetted Tub, Updated Kitchen, Double Oven, Wall Oven, Countertop Cooking, Gas Range, Vaulted Ceilings, Instantaneous Hot Water, Granite Countertops, Theater Room, Video Door Bell(s), Video Camera(s)
Flooring: Carpet, Hardwood, Tile
Window Coverings: Blinds, Drapes, Part
Heating: Forced Air, Central Gas
Air Conditioning: Central Air
Utilities: Natural Gas Connected, Electricity Connected, Sewer Connected, Septic Tank, Water Connected

Private Showing

Tony Fantis, Realtor<sup>®</sup>
For showing appointments, call Tony Fantis, Realtor® to view the home at 5331 Sleepy Hollow Ln in Nibley. Give Tony Fantis, Realtor® a call at (801) 541-8806.
5331 Sleepy Hollow Ln was listed on Mar 26th, 2025 by Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Elite Real Estate, a real estate brokerage. 801-224-9011 is the contact info for the listing brokerage contact assigned for this listing.

 Mortgage Calculator

Estimated Monthly Payment
/ month*
Modify your down payment, price, or interest rate to estimate a payment.
Purchase Price $
Down Payment %
Interest Rate %
Repayment (years)
Property Tax $
HOA Fee $
Estimated payments and calculations are provided for informational purposes only. Actual payments can vary based on many factors.
*Insurance must usually be added to your monthly payment. Costs vary based on many factors. Consult your insurance agent, your Realtor®, and your lender.

Take it on the road with you...

QR code for 5331  Sleepy Hollow Ln.
Scan this QR code into your mobile device and take this listing with you.

If you have a smartphone, just point your camera at the code. This page will appear on your phone.

You May Also Like...


5986 E Big Horn Pkwy
                     MLS #2031244
$1,699,000
BedroomsBathroomsGarage spaces
3,828 Sq Ft
946 S Meadow Lark Ln
                     MLS #2070807
$1,699,000
BedroomsBathroomsGarage spaces
4,774 Sq Ft
1154  Fawn
                     MLS #2073678
$1,699,000
BedroomsBathroomsGarage spaces
6,156 Sq Ft
5161 E Moose Hollow Dr #101
                     MLS #2070504
$1,700,000
BedroomsBathroomsGarage spaces
3,116 Sq Ft
5786 N Porcupine Ridge Dr #91
                     MLS #2019744
$1,747,274
BedroomsBathroomsGarage spaces
5,000 Sq Ft
5985 E Big Horn Pkwy #137
                     MLS #1978249
$1,765,000
BedroomsBathroomsGarage spaces
4,437 Sq Ft
5713 E Elkhorn Dr
                     MLS #2062665
$1,795,000
BedroomsBathrooms 719 Garage spaces
5,268 Sq Ft
Scroll up
Scroll up

TonyFantis.com shows ALL available properties from the MLS in Utah (WFRMLS), including any property that is pending, under contract, accepting backup offers, or actively seeking buyers.